Energy Efficiency: Hyperscale vs. Multi-Tenant

Jan. 5, 2016
The experts in our Data Center Frontier Executive Roundtable examine trends in data center energy efficiency and how they differ across market segments.

Today we continue our Data Center Executive Roundtable, a quarterly feature showcasing the insights of thought leaders on the state of the data center industry, and where it is headed. In today’s discussion, our panel of three experienced data center executives – Jakob Carnemark of Aligned Data Centers, Robert McClary of FORTRUST, and James Leach of RagingWire Data Centers – will examine trends in data center energy efficiency and how they differ across market segments. The conversation is moderated by Rich Miller, the founder and editor of Data Center Frontier.

Data Center Energy Efficiency: Hyperscale vs. Multi-Tenant

Data Center Frontier: Hyperscale single-company data centers have traditionally been the leaders in energy efficiency. How would you assess the progress of multi-tenant providers in improving PUEs and efficiency?

Jakob Carnemark, Aligned Data Centers

Jakob Carnemark: Large hyperscale data centers have a much greater cost advantage then just low PUE (Power Usage Effectiveness, the leading efficiency metric) . It’s the higher utilization of the infrastructure that really drives efficiency. The average company in colocation or owned assets spends 10x more on low infrastructure utilization than on higher PUEs. The barriers to efficiency are the unpredictably of IT loads and the static nature of infrastructure.

The colocation industry thus far has focused on delivering real estate without focusing on improving the underlying IT delivery model. This is a core issue that Aligned has focused on addressing in the industry. We are launching a data center platform that flexes to density changes in the same rack footprint. The data centers deliver a flat PUE curve of 1.15 guaranteed regardless of load and use 85 percent less water than traditional cooling approaches.

Robert McClary: It’s absolutely true (that hyperscale data centers are the most efficient). Single-company data centers have much more control over the hardware and IT environments, so it’s much easier to be energy efficient. Multi-tenant data centers or colocation providers have several different challenges.

Robert McClary, FORTRUST

The first is how customers are putting their IT environments in place. Increasing cold or delivery aisle temperatures by a few degrees, or utilizing different containment strategies, is much harder to do in a multi-tenant data center than in one in which you have control through to the end-user stack.

Customer perception is another factor that creates several different challenges. We’ve had to understand that the end-user or customer’s perception, a lot of times, trumps good operational practices. The challenge is how to educate all the end users on what is in everybody’s best interests. There are too many competing theories and misperceptions around good data center operational strategies.

James Leach: Comparing hyperscale single-company data centers and multi-tenant providers in terms of energy efficiency is like comparing a bus to a fleet of mini-vans. When fully loaded, the bus will be more efficient, but the mini-vans will provide more flexibility. Both approaches are far superior to everyone driving themselves.

James Leach, RagingWire Data Centers

The reality is both hyperscale single-company data centers and multi-tenant data centers are making great advances in solving the energy efficiency equation – the variables are the same, only the constants are different. Hyperscale data centers can drive greater efficiency than multi-tenant data centers because they can require higher levels of standardization. Multi-tenant data centers have to support a more diverse user base, so mass standardization is not possible.

The good news is that both hyperscale and multi-tenant data centers are maximizing the energy efficiency of their environments. Both approaches are vastly superior to running your computers in a general purpose office space.

NEXT: The Blurring Boundaries Between Wholesale and Colo

Keep pace with the fact-moving world of data centers and cloud computing by following us on Twitter and Facebook, connecting with me on LinkedIn, and signing up for our weekly newspaper using the form below:

About the Author

Rich Miller

I write about the places where the Internet lives, telling the story of data centers and the people who build them. I founded Data Center Knowledge, the data center industry's leading news site. Now I'm exploring the future of cloud computing at Data Center Frontier.

Sponsored Recommendations

Optimizing AI Infrastructure: The Critical Role of Liquid Cooling

In this executive brief, we discuss the growing need for liquid cooling in data centers due to the increasing power demands of AI and high-performance computing. Discover how ...

AI-Driven Data Centers: Revolutionizing Decarbonization Strategies

AI hype has put data centers in the spotlight, sparking concerns over energy use—but they’re also key to a greener future. With renewable power and cutting-edge cooling, data ...

Bending the Energy Curve: Decoupling Digitalization Trends from Data Center Energy Growth

After a decade of stability, data center energy consumption is now set to surge—but can we change the trajectory? Discover how small efficiency gains could cut energy growth by...

AI Reference Designs to Enable Adoption: A Collaboration Between Schneider Electric and NVIDIA

Traditional data center power, cooling, and racks aren’t sufficient for GPU-based servers arranged in high-density AI clusters...

Courtesy of Stream Data Centers
Image courtesy of Stream Data Centers

The Rise of the “Fake” Data Center Developer — And How to Tell the Difference

Stream Data Centers’ Co-Managing Partners expand on the problem of “fake” data center developers and explain how investors and end users can separate the wheat from the chaff....

White Papers

Get the Full Report

Using Simulation to Validate Cooling Design

April 21, 2022
Kao Data’s UK data center is designed to sustainably support high performance computing and intensive artificial intelligence. Future Facilities explores how CFD can validated...